Posts Tagged pgw
Today I’m talking with Marc Talbert, Vice President and Managing Partner with Guardian Auto Glass, LLC. Marc was formerly the president of PGW Auto Glass Wholesale, LLC until he left the auto glass manufacturer and wholesaler in late 2009. In the Fall of 2010 Marc, along with Jim Latch (a former executive with PGW Auto Glass and PPG Industries, Inc.); and Jerry Ray and Neil Smith (who passed away on June 17, 2011) who together were founders involved with Glass Pro and Elite Auto Glass formed a partnership titled LRST LLC. The four equal partners joined with Guardian Industries and LRST was given the management responsibilities of Guardian Auto Glass, LLC. This unique partnership was formed to grow the number of stores under the Guardian Auto Glass banner. The goal is for Guardian Auto Glass to provide automobile glass repair and replacement (AGRR) services using a local ownership/management model. The model looks very similar to the one that Wes Topping and his partners (including Jerry Ray and Neil Smith) used to rapidly grow Elite Auto Glass across the western United States before selling to Belron in 2005. Guardian Industries Corp. had owned the platform for years. At this time Guardian Auto Glass operates over 90 stores in Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Virginia and West Virginia.
DR: I know that you and your partners have been busy the past two years working on growing Guardian Auto Glass and I appreciate you taking the time to talk with me today Marc.
MT: Thank you for the opportunity to participate.
DR: What year did you get your start in the AGRR industry and what was your first position in the industry?
MT: My ARG (automotive replacement glass) experience began in 1994 as manager of PPG’s branch distribution centers in Dallas/Ft Worth. I started my career with PPG in 1980.
DR: What were the positions and responsibilities you’ve had since you first started in the industry in 1994?
MT: I relocated to Southern California in 1995 as manager of PPG’s western distribution locations, then to Pittsburgh in 2003 with responsibility for PPG Auto Glass, LLC.
DR: Which of those jobs did you find most interesting and why? And which was the worst one and why?
MT: Honestly all were equally interesting because they presented increasing challenges and responsibilities. Working in the field for the first 23 years of my career I anticipated the move to PPG’s corporate office would be the most intimidating, but I was fortunate to work with some very good people who made the transition much easier, and even enjoyable.
DR: You left PGW Auto Glass in 2009 as a President and your responsibilities at PGW included wholesale sales and distribution for the company. What made you jump from the wholesale side of the AGRR industry to retail?
MT: I had the opportunity to partner with Jim Latch who I had worked with at PPG and two of our long-time customers Jerry Ray and Neil Smith. Jerry and Neil brought significant and successful retail experience along with a proven business model, and together we saw an opportunity to partner with a company like Guardian to expand their retail business. There remains quite a gap between the largest US retail provider and the next largest and one of our goals is to try and reduce this gap.
DR: About a year after you entered the LRST partnership Neil Smith sadly passed away. Did his passing change the plans you’d made in your goals at Guardian Auto Glass?
MT: Neil’s passing was certainly a shock to us and we miss his experience and counsel every day, not to mention his humor. Our plans to grow Guardian Auto Glass will be more difficult to achieve without Neil but we have not altered our plans.
DR: What are your key responsibilities at Guardian Auto Glass?
MT: Jerry and I share the responsibilities for new market growth and acquisitions, and Jim has responsibility for managing the legacy Guardian locations and our administrative support center in Worthington, Ohio. We all share responsibility for the management of Guardian Auto Glass.
DR: Did you find the retail side of the AGRR industry a little harder than you had expected it to be?
MT: I think you ultimately have similar issues with retail and distribution, or any business for that matter. As you effectively pointed out in a recent blog you try to attract the best people and provide enough support for them to succeed without bogging them down with non-value added work. That is the focus of our business and the core of our local ownership model, and what we believe differentiates Guardian Auto Glass in each of our markets. Having local owners with a stake in our collective success changes many aspects and costs of traditional corporate management, and we believe is the key to growing profitably.
The primary difference we’ve learned in retail is the need in some cases and with certain third-party administrators to retain customers who have chosen a Guardian Auto Glass location to complete work we’ve already sold through our local marketing and customer relationships. This is a dynamic we did not face in distribution and one we are increasingly concerned with.
DR: How many brick and mortar locations did Guardian Auto Glass have before you partnered with Guardian on this new venture versus the number that the company has today? How are you doing on achieving the strategic goals that were set for the first two years of the venture?
MT: We currently pay rent at over 90 locations and I believe Guardian had 25-30 locations when we started. The economy and lack of weather is certainly not generating a tailwind for us this year but we have continued to expand as anticipated and build a competitive infrastructure.
DR: Many in the industry are waiting for Guardian Auto Glass to do something with the call center/third party administration (TPA) that you operate, especially with Jim Latch participation in the partnership. Does Guardian Auto Glass have any plans to become a bigger factor in the call center or TPA side of the industry?
MT: Guardian’s network is not part of Guardian Auto Glass and is not operated by LRST. As you point out Jim’s experience in this area provides a unique opportunity for us and we anticipate working with Guardian’s network to help expand both businesses.
DR: What advice can you offer other retailers on how to successfully compete against Safelite®?
MT: I don’t think we are in a position to provide advice to anyone, but we are concerned as I’m sure many ARG retailers are with maintaining access to our customers who have chosen to have their vehicle glass serviced by one of our Guardian Auto Glass locations. We will continue to direct our efforts and investments in building our local customer relationships, and retaining access to those customers will be an area of increased focus for us going forward.
DR: Where do you see Guardian Auto Glass in 5 years? What will make you and your partners feel that it will be a success?
MT: Our mission is to grow profitably through our local ownership model and to continue our expansion, so we will need to see how we measure up at the end of our 5th year. We remain excited about the opportunities in the ARG retail market and will continue to seek strategic partners and existing businesses in all markets to help us reach our goals.
DR: How’s your golf game coming along? I know that in some circles you’re considered to be a tough guy to beat in a game.
MT: Must be very small circles, however I would welcome a rematch with you and others free from the constraints of customer golf.
DR: Perhaps. I look forward to the opportunity to a rematch. Some of my team members I’m going to change out, as I would guess you will too. Loser pays?
Thank you again for taking the time to talk with me Marc. I know that many in the industry are looking for someone, some company to step up and take on Safelite. Perhaps Guardian Auto Glass can be one that does. Good luck in achieving the goals that you have for Guardian Auto Glass.
Aftermarket glass, AGR, agrr industry, agrss, ARG, Arizona, auto glass, Auto Glass Company, auto glass industry, Auto Insurance, Belron, California, call center, Colorado, customer, customer relationships, Florida, Georgia, golf, golfing, Guardian, Guardian Auto Glass, Indiana, Insurance, Insurance Industry, Jerry Ray, Jim Latch, just sayin', kentucky, local, local marketing, LRST, Marc Talbert, michigan, Neil Smith, OEM Glass, Ohio, Pennsylvania, pgw, PGW Auto Glass, PPG, PPG Industries, safelite, safelite auto glass, safelite solutions, state govt., tpa, US Govt, virginia, West Virginia, windshield, windshield repair, windshield replacement, windshields
There have certainly been a number of events happening since the first of the year that are effecting or may affect the auto glass repair and replacement (AGRR) industry in 2012. Where to start? Well let’s see:
1. First the earth shook on January 2, 2012, when Safelite® Solutions officially took over the responsibilities for administrating Allstate® Insurance auto glass claims from PGW Lynxservices®. By all accounts Safelite® Solutions must be doing a masterful job in this new role administering claims for Allstate® as I’ve heard from a number of you that your auto glass claims from the second largest insurer in the United States are dramatically lower since the administrator change took place. Mild weather could also be a contributing factor. Adding to the pain of lost units, the pricing for those Allstate® replacements are also lower.
Have you seen your auto glass claims with Allstate decline since January 2, 2012?
2. On January 6, 2012, glassBYTEs.com™ reported that Grey Mountain Partners Acquires Binswanger. Binswanger is a truly amazing full-service glass company with its roots going back to 1872 with its first location in Richmond, Virginia. It is certainly great news to hear for all of the Binswanger employees that they have a new owner who is interested in working with them to help build the company. I think that a strong Binswanger is healthy for the glass industry in the United States.
How about you?
3. Neil Duffy recently announced in his very well written blog View From The Trenches that he’s considering a new career by starting a ‘new third-party glass claims administrator’. It sounds as though he’s thought it out pretty thoroughly by looking at all the pros of this new venture and I for one think he should go for it. I don’t see any cons.
What do you think?
4. Then there is that anonymous letter from a ‘Concerned Citizen’ that surfaced yet again last week titled “New Anti-Trust Concerns”. This letter had a postmark from Bloomington, Illinois, and its resurfacing at this time might have some relationship to #1 above.
It does seem pretty obvious that the letter was written by someone in the auto glass industry as no one else would really care about the issue. The letter does raise a number of interesting points, but the conclusion of the ‘Concerned Citizen’ is that:
‘While the relationship between a TPA and its insurance company clients may not be illegal, the abuse of that position could be unfairly excluding independent competitors.’
There are a number AGRR initiatives taking place in various states where attempts are being made to try to restrict the big guy from taking your lunch money day in and day out. If one of them was successful it would certainly be good for independents in the industry.
Are there any legislative initiatives happening in your state that will be of any help to you in your business?
5. For those of you who happen to follow @Safelite on Twitter you may have seen them sending out ‘Tweets’ asking for your input. One ‘Tweet’ poses a question to its followers and directs you to a web page survey question asking ‘How likely are you to recommend Safelite?’ Safelite® gives you the opportunity to answer with a ‘Not Likely’ – 0 score to an ‘Extremely Likely’ – 10 score.
I’m not sure to whom exactly Safelite® is targeting the question, but you’ve got to provide an email address in order to answer the question which is somewhat problematical. If you’d like to offer your view anonymously I guess you could use a fake email address.
I know what my number is in answer to the question. What number would you mark as your answer?
6. And finally there was an article in the Chicago Tribune on January 18, 2012, reporting that the average age of vehicles in the United States has climbed to 10.8 years. The article stated that in 2010 the average age of vehicles was 10.6 years with the average age of vehicles having climbed steadily since 1995 when it was at 8.5 years. Over the past several years low new vehicle sales has certainly been a major factor in the increase in the average age, but with new car sales picking up new car manufacturers are expecting a great year in 2012. That will help to slow the growth in average age and hopefully bring it down. What does average age have to do with the AGRR industry?
One byproduct of an aging vehicle fleet is that you see an increasing number of the ‘do nothings’ (consumers that delay replacements) when auto glass breaks. Consumers obviously will be more accepting of a repair over replacement if the vehicle is older. New vehicles typically provide a higher average invoice value since the only replacement glass initially available to consumers will be auto glass manufactured for the vehicle by the Original Equipment Manufactured (OEM) glass company (i.e. Pilkington-NSG, PGW, Saint-Gobain Sekurit, etc.). The cost for non-OEM manufactures to reverse-engineer a replacement part for new vehicles is initially too expensive due to the low volume of parts needed in the aftermarket. The older the age of the vehicle fleet the more opportunities for non-OEM suppliers to sell reverse engineered replacement parts that are typically cheaper than the OEM’s. Ultimately that can mean less profit for the AGRR industry as a whole. New vehicle sales should mean more profit opportunities for those in the AGRR industry.
What do you think?
I hesitate to mention other things going on so far this year that may have an effect on your business like the lack of a severe winter in the East, the predictions for much higher gasoline prices later this year, a sputtering economy, the price changes that have taken place in the State Farm® Insurance Company auto glass program and various people coming and going from here to there. How you’re dealing with the variety of issues that you’ll face in 2012 will determine how you survive the year. Someone I’ve known for a long time in the industry commented to me last week that, ‘2012 is shaping up to be a watershed year for many in the industry. Survive this year and hope that next year will be a better one.’ That outlook makes sense to me. We’ll see if he’s right.
In closing, a former Princeton University men’s basketball coach by the name of Pete Carril wrote a book titled “The Smart Take from the Strong”. It’s a great book. Pete Carril was 5’6” tall, he was an All-State Pennsylvania high school basketball player, an Associated Press Little All-American in college and he coached at Princeton for 29 years before going on to the NBA to become an assistant coach for the Sacramento Kings. Coach Carril is also a member of the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame. When he was young man his father told him:
‘The strong take from the weak, but the smart take from the strong.’
So be smart in 2012!
2012, Aftermarket glass, AGR, AGRR, AGRR Magazine, agrss, AGRSS Standard, allstate, allstate insurance, ANSI, anti-trust, auto glass, Auto Glass Company, auto glass industry, Auto Glass Replacement Safety Standard, Auto Glass Safety, Auto Glass Safety Council, Auto Glass Week, Auto Insurance, Automotive Expert, automotive safety, basketball, binswanger, chicago, chicago tribune, coach, coach pete carril, concerned citizen, David Rohlfing, economy, federal govt, Fox News Channel, glassbytes, government, grey mountain partners, IGA, illinois, independent, Insurance, Insurance Industry, just sayin', legislation, lynxservices, neil duffy, No Shortcut to Safety, OEM Glass, pete carril, pgw, Pilkington, princeton, princeton university, safelite, safelite auto glass, safelite solutions, saint-gobain, Small business, state farm, state govt., the economy, tpa, twitter, US Govt, vehicles, view from the trenches, windshield, windshield repair, windshields, winter
- August 2019
- July 2019
- February 2019
- December 2018
- May 2018
- February 2018
- December 2017
- July 2017
- September 2016
- February 2016
- November 2015
- October 2015
- January 2015
- December 2014
- October 2014
- September 2014
- August 2014
- July 2014
- June 2014
- May 2014
- April 2014
- March 2014
- February 2014
- January 2014
- December 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- August 2013
- July 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- August 2012
- July 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- March 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- aumotive after-market
- Auto Glass
- Auto Glass Networks
- Auto Glass Safety Council
- Big Data
- Boston Marathon
- Business Icon
- Call Centers
- Collision Repair Industry
- Congressional Medal of Honor
- Disruptive Innovation
- driverless car
- Driverless Cars
- electric cars
- Federal Reserve
- Ford Motor Company
- Fortune 500
- General Motors
- Golden State Warriors
- July 4th
- Memorial Day
- Military Service
- New Year
- No Bad Ideas
- PPG Industries
- President George H.W. Bush
- recipe for success
- rental cars
- Rube Goldberg
- self-driving car
- Sika Corporation
- state government
- Super Bowl
- Third Party Administrator – TPA
- U.S. Govt.
- United Kingdom
- Vince Lombardi Trophy
- The New Normal davidrohlfingblog.wordpress.com/2019/08/20/the… 2 days ago
- RT @pulte: I will give $11,294 or a Bitcoin to someone random who retweets this in the next 72 hours (must be following me so I can dm you) 1 week ago
- Here's a GREAT article on #TRUST in business written by @paulzak. Great read! #leadershipmatters #leadership twitter.com/HarvardBiz/sta… 1 month ago